The Miami Dolphins’ quarterback situation has been a recurring problem, and it’s essential to address the issue to avoid another disappointing season. Tua Tagovailoa’s unreliability due to injuries has highlighted the need for a trustworthy backup quarterback.
In 2024, the Dolphins’ backup quarterback situation was inadequate, with Tyler Huntley and Skylar Thompson failing to provide a reliable solution. Thompson has since moved to the Pittsburgh Steelers, leaving the Dolphins to search for a new backup quarterback.
General manager Chris Grier acknowledged the need to strengthen the backup quarterback position, citing the salary cap as a hindrance to securing better options last year. To resolve this issue, the Dolphins should consider the following four quarterbacks:
Potential Backup Quarterback Options for the Dolphins in 2025
Justin Fields
Fields is an intriguing option, despite his limitations as a quarterback. He has shown the ability to fill in effectively, which is essential for a backup quarterback. Fields’ experience in Pittsburgh has provided valuable tape for NFL teams, demonstrating his capability to run an offense.
Fields led the Steelers to a 4-2 start, throwing for 1,106 yards, five touchdowns, and one interception. He also showcased his rushing abilities, accumulating 289 yards and five scores. However, his price tag might be a deterrent for the Dolphins, who will be cap-strapped in 2025.
Marcus Mariota
Mariota is another viable option, bringing a wealth of experience and a pre-existing relationship with Tua Tagovailoa. Mariota’s familiarity with the Dolphins’ quarterback would facilitate a smoother transition, and his ability to start if needed would provide a sense of security.
Mariota’s price might be more manageable for the Dolphins compared to Fields, and his experience would be a valuable asset to the team. He could quickly grasp the offense and perform better than the Dolphins’ recent backup quarterbacks.
Jameis Winston
Winston is a third option, having demonstrated his ability to move the ball despite being thrust into a challenging situation with the Cleveland Browns. Winston’s experience as a starter would be beneficial in a backup role, and his locker-room presence would likely have a positive impact on his teammates.
Winston threw for 2,121 yards, 13 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions in 2024. While he tends to turn the ball over, he can also get the ball to playmakers. His experience and leadership qualities make him an attractive option for the Dolphins.
Jimmy Garoppolo
Garoppolo is the fourth and final option, bringing a level of familiarity with head coach Mike McDaniel’s system. Garoppolo’s experience with the San Francisco 49ers, where McDaniel was an assistant coach, would facilitate a smooth transition.
Garoppolo has proven himself as a capable backup quarterback, having taken the 49ers to the Super Bowl in the past. He would provide a sense of security for the Dolphins, knowing that he can handle the job for a few games if needed.
The Dolphins must prioritize finding a reliable backup quarterback to avoid another disappointing season. With these four options, they can strengthen their quarterback position and provide a sense of security for Tua Tagovailoa.
The Dolphins’ quarterback situation has been a recurring problem, and it’s essential to address the issue to avoid another disappointing season. By considering these four options, the Dolphins can take a crucial step towards resolving their backup quarterback woes.
As the Dolphins navigate the offseason, they must keep their priorities in mind. Securing a reliable backup quarterback should be at the top of their list, and these four options provide a solid starting point.
Ultimately, the Dolphins’ success in 2025 will depend on their ability to address their backup quarterback situation. By making the right move, they can provide a sense of security for Tua Tagovailoa and strengthen their chances of a successful season.
Leave a Reply